Alarm bells should be going off for Agatha All Along fans right now. Good…alarm bells. The show may be sliding into one of those rare scenarios where despite originally being conceived as a miniseries, or at best, a lead-in to another show, it may in fact be getting a season 2, according to new evidence.

Agatha All Along Season 2 has fans buzzing with speculation, wondering if Kathryn Hahn will return to her memorable role in the dark comedy fantasy series. The show, created by Jac Schaeffer, recently wrapped up its first season,